Scrooge Strategy

Part 6 of the car debacle

Part 1 of this story
Part 2
Part 3
Part 4
Part 5

Yesterday, “John” finally emailed me. I’m not really sure what to even say, so I’ll just paste some of the email conversation.

Yeah I did trade the car for a different one. The price was about 10% more than the original car deal. What happened was I went down there on Monday, saying I wanted to return it, because of the ridiculous APR and I didn’t really like the car… they said I had no grace period and was the owner, and the only thing they could do for me was trade it for something else. So my new plan was to get a car for 10k to minimize finance charges(they wouldn’t finance anything less they say) but they were jerking me around so much every time I asked about seeing the car they would say it was sold or tell me it would cost at least 5-6k more than what it was listed on the website, with “bank fees” or something ridiculous. They were obviously ONLY going to get me into a car of equal or greater value. They realized they had all the power and weren’t enthused about helping get out of the car that A: I didn’t really want, B: couldn’t afford. So I could have paid 15k on a 9 thousand dollar car, or I could get a car that I liked, that was actually worth what it was being sold to me for.

I could have said “no, get me out of this car deal or I will leave the car here and ignore the payments”, but I knew I would be paying for my poor credit sooner or later, so I decided to get into a car I liked, and then pursue refinancing.

We went back and forth a little bit, and then he replied with refreshing honesty:

The bottom line is that I don’t see myself as the innocent victim of the crooked dealership like Vincent does. I should have made absolutely clear about the grace period, and I shouldn’t have been considering such an expensive car at a high interest rate in the first place. I am the victim of my own ignorance and my impulsive actions.

At this point I am looking to make the best of a bad situation, and build my credit in the process.

We all make bad choices sometimes, so while it’s fun to point out what poor decision-making went into this process, I also felt sorry for him. My friend Josh at the Credit Union National Association had put out the word for help and, within an hour, he had gotten me in touch with the Colorado State Employees Credit Union.

Here’s the cool part: One of their employees, Melissa Sexe, sent me an email and offered to chat with John to see what options he had. Can you imagine Wells Fargo taking note of this and volunteering to help? This is one of the reasons I love credit unions.

I sent Melissa’s info to John (here’s why I did it that way, not the other way around). So now it’s on John. Let’s see what happens.

PS–Thanks to Melissa at the Colorado State Employees Credit Union and Josh at the Credit Union National Association. Even if they can’t help John, I think it speaks enormously highly of them that they offered to try to help so quickly.

Get chapter 1 of my New York Times best-selling book for free

Sign up for my newsletter and I will send you my first chapter instantly

  • Free negotiation scripts
  • Bonus entrepreneurship videos
  • Tactics to earn more money

15 comments

Leave your own

  1. 1
    February 1, 2007

    Interesting story and interesting admission by “John” – I have a friend (well now three of them) who are in the process of getting wrapped up in Amway/Quixtar. I have tried repeatedly to show them why it is such a hoax. They choose not to listen and – maybe one day when it comes down to it and they realize that a) they have lost a lot of money and b) they are doing things in a pyramid scheme they will admit their own ignorance. It’s very easy to get wrapped up in your friends problems/decisions – it’s really only because you care….but in the end…”you can lead a horse to water, but…”

  2. 2
    February 1, 2007

    Don’t do Amway.

  3. 3
    February 1, 2007

    Very interesting. What continues to amaze me about the Americans is that you always seem to have to “build good credit”. I don’t understand that concept. At 35 years, I never had any debt and I don’t think I ever will have any. I just don’t need to “build good credit”. In which way is the German money system different from the American one? Or is the perceived neccessity to build “good” credit just an excuse to get into debt?

  4. 4
    February 1, 2007

    Holy Cow! Why DO we have to go into debt to build good credit? I’ve never really thought of it that way before, but that is kind of true. Think about it. The FICO credit rating really does reward those who go (at least temporarily) into debt.
    I guess the easy answer is that you don’t really have to go into debt. What you have to do is show that you can responsibly pay back any money that you borrow so when the time comes to purchase something big like a house or a business loan the lending institutions can look at your track record and see that you are likely to pay them back on time. If you have a bad track record or no track record, they won’t trust you and they’re going to want more money for their risk in the form of a higher interest rate.
    One way to show responsibility without actually being in debt is to pay off all of your credit cards every month. Ironically, the more credit cards you have (to an extent) the more you are rewarded because debt-to-income ratio is one factor used in your FICO score. But having a car loan that is being paid on time is great for your credit–much better than if you walked into the dealership and paid for a vehicle in cash.
    Of course, I’m not sure what you were expecting from us when our government can’t even come close to staying out of debt and last year the average American savings rate was actually NEGATIVE (meaning that Americans as a whole spent more money last year than they made!). So much for saving 10% of your salary.
    Such is the American way I suppose! :)

  5. 5
    February 1, 2007

    Longtime sometimes reader, first time commenter.

    @fubek: I don’t know how it works in Germany, but here in the US it is fairly complicated. You can build a good credit score just by obtaining and using credit — not necessarily by going into debt. I am talking about very short-term debt (1 month) on credit cards. I explain a lot of it on my blog.

    @Ramit: I have to say I don’t really understand why you posted all of this or why you went to any effort to help the guy. It’s just a guy making a dumb mistake, buying more car than he can afford, and getting buyer’s remorse. It happens all the time. But this situation set a precedent that you may not want (”Help me Ramit, I don’t know you from Adam but I got into some money trouble! Please call some of your friends for me!”).

    BTW, I’m not positive that I can fix your blog, but I am a programmer and would like to try banging on it. Er, banging on a copy of it. Just for fun.

  6. 6
    February 1, 2007

    FFR, anyone who is thinking of buying a new car or the like, head over to http://www.carbuyingtips.com first, to if anything, understand how the processes work many times…so you don’t end up making an ignorant decision like this (not that you would now, but something similar).

  7. 7
    February 2, 2007

    Well, good for John. I give him credit for standing up and taking responsibility for his own actions, instead of going the “poor me” route. Successful people take responsibility.

    And if he can learn from his mistakes (including the mistake of not asking for help) and apply these learnings to future decisions, I think he’ll take away from the lesson more than he lost.

  8. 8
    February 2, 2007

    I don’t think he’s learned anything. So instead of paying $15k on a $9k car, he’s now going to pay $28k on a $19k car?

    I can just picture Peter Griffin saying “Yeah… I’ll give them more money. That’ll show em.”

  9. 9
    February 2, 2007

    I only buy cars from a dealership whose stated policy is that they only charge $500 over what they paid for each car. They will not negotiate price at all. Their prices are always well below kelly blue book, which is why I believe them. They also do not offer any financing so you have to arrange outside financing. It’s been a great way to buy cars. They don’t sell any sexy cars–only used, clean title, Hondas, Toyotas and Nissans mostly. But we all know what sexy gets us, don’t we? Just ask John.

  10. 10
    February 2, 2007

    It is not necessary to build your credit history or have credit cards. If you don’t have the money, don’t buy it. If you need a car, save up and buy something super-cheap. Then save up some more, and upgrade.

    If you want to get a mortgage, you can get a mortgage with manual underwriting instead of a mortgage based on a credit score.

  11. 11
    February 2, 2007

    I would have to say “John’s” best course of action if he doesn’t get a new loan is to definitely set up automatic payment for his car payment. To prevent any forgotten or late payments. (And if possible pay $50-100 more than the minimum).

  12. 12
    February 3, 2007

    … *is speechless*

    In fact, this ordeal is so blatantly disturbing that it just crashed my system

    hmph =^..^=

  13. 13
    February 3, 2007

    Boy, you are stretching this car debacle thread too much!!
    Lets have some finance posts (sorry, I don’t mean to sound rude)

  14. 14
    February 8, 2007

    It’s probably way too late for this to have any chance of working, but there is one tactic that can occasionally work in situations like this.

    Dealerships rarely carry their own contracts. They are nearly always sold to the financing institution (like a local bank, Chrysler Credit, GMAC, Ford Motor Credit, etc.).

    One can call up the financial institution, bypassing the dealership entirely, and tell them that ‘yes, I realize this is a contract and it’s legal. BUT–the dealership hoodwinked me and I can NOT afford this payment. If you buy this contract, I will NOT make the payments. I know I will be stuck with penalties and all kinds of stuff, but I simply cannot do it.’

    Financial institutions are not really wanting to buy a contract that will go into default right out of the box. They lose, and it costs the dealership nothing, as most contracts from big dealers are purchased on a ‘non-recourse’ basis, meaning that once the contract is funded, the FI has no recourse against the dealer .

    Another way to contest an obviously outrageous contract is to threaten the dealer with action through the Attorney General’s office alleging improper disclosure of contract terms. There is a box on the contract that states the amount borrowed, rate, etc., and it MUST be covered with the borrower by federal law. A lot of F & I guys will gloss over this section of the contract so the borrower doesn’t get scared. If that happens, then the borrower does have a little bit of recourse–the basis of a threat, if nothing else.

  15. 15
    February 9, 2007

    Hey Ramit:

    Did you receive my email on this topic? Email me and say you didn’t and I’ll resend it.

    Cool site. And a mention in the NYT. Wow.

How much have you saved
using Ramit's advice?





$
Only numbers please