But it’s not just about why I think stocks are better. Many of you have been hearing about the blog http://www.iamfacingforeclosure.com, written by a 24-year-old guy named Casey Serin who “bought 8 houses in 8 months across 4 states with no money down” and is now facing foreclosure. He has openly admitted to lying on his loan applications (to get more in loans), and to bringing his total debt to about $2.2 million ($140,000 of that is in unsecured debt like credit cards). In the meantime, he’s been blogging about his situation. His blog has gotten the attention of USA Today, the San Francisco Chronicle, NPR, and more.
There’s a twist to this story that nobody else knows: I know Casey Serin. We went to high school together. In fact, we ran the computer club together, which is how I got to be the cool guy I am today.
That makes this a weird post to write–not only because he’s done some really shady stuff that really pisses me off, but because he’s not just a one-dimensional character who deserves our scorn: He’s actually doing a lot of good, too. And that makes it hard to describe what I really think of the situation.
The story with me actually begins about a month ago, when I got an email from Casey out of the blue. I hadn’t heard from him since high school 6 years ago. (Emails reprinted with permission.)
From: Casey Serin
To: [BCC list]
I hate SPAM too! You’re receiving this because you’re in my personal mailing list. You’re a friend, family or an acquaintance or past co-worker or client. If you don’t want to receive occasion updates from me please use the automatic unsubscribe link at the bottom. Thanks!
Long time no talk! Yes I have not been good at updating everybody and keeping in touch. So here is a 1) quick update about what I’ve been up to, and 2) an opportunity to put your money to work with us in the real estate business
This January I quit my job to do real estate investing full-time. Together with partners in the area we buy and sell houses for fast gains and we also hold property for appreciation. In the first part of the year I personally bought 7 houses in 4 different states. It’s not all easy – there is definitely a learning curve. It helps to have experienced associates to help me along.
We have a unique opportunity to continue to expand the real estate business. Because of the market reversal in California there is going to be many people in trouble with their loans. People have been buying more home then they can afford or refinancing like crazy. Foreclosures are already on the rise and they are going to sky-rocket in the next several years.
There is an opportunity to 1) help people out of trouble and 2) make some money. Service and integrity comes first though. I know what its like to be behind payments and face foreclosure. I refuse to be a “shark” investor.
It must be win-win, or no deal.
Want to participate?
Do you have money that’s sitting in an account somewhere earning an embarrassing 1-3%? Are you comfortable with your retirment money sitting in a volatile stock-market?
Maybe you’re not investing at all. Are you comfortable trusting social security to take care of your retirement?
Invest your money with us and get 24% fixed return secured by real estate.
We use your money to buy and fix houses improving the area and helping sellers in distress.
Benefits to becoming our private lender:
* we pay fixed 24% interest on your money – reliable returns
* compounded monthly – your interest is making interest and it grows exponentially
* secured by real estate – just like a bank, YOU get a mortgage against our properties to protect your investment
* start with as little as 10,000
* may use your 401K or IRA account – get tax advantages
* your money doubles every 3 years
* 10,000 grows into 100,000 in 10 years
Worst case scenario…
If we can’t pay you back, you get a good property. We only put your money into a house that has at least twice the equity as the amount you’re investing. We only invest into nice properties in good neighborhoods. If something were to happen to our business you can normally just sell the house at a discount and get your money out. What stock or mutual fund is going to give you THAT kind of security?
We can only take a certain number of private lenders. Get back to me soon so I can explain in more detail.
Also please forward this to anybody else who may want to get a high return on their money. We pay referral fees!
I would love to hear from you either way. Lets catch-up!
You can imagine my disbelief in getting this email. Here’s an old acquaintance who I haven’t heard from in years, and he pitches me the shadiest-sounding financial “opportunity” I’ve ever heard of. “Fixed 24% interest on your money – reliable returns”? Oh really? Give me a break. When I read that, I immediately knew this “offer” was BS, but just to play along, I asked him what the risks of his idea were. He replied:
From: Casey Serin
To: Ramit Sethi
1) Getting into a bad deal. Minimize with experience. I’ve been investing full time since Jan of this year and dabbled part time for about a year before. I’ve already made my share of mistakes and learned from them. (Good blogging material!) So I’m still pretty new but not BRAND new. To fill in the gaps in my knowledge I work with other experienced investors who help me and partner on deals with me. That’s the “we” part.
2) Private lender needs his/her money out early. Minimize with having other lenders on stand-by. I would not try to keep a private lender locked-in. If I can find another lender to take their place then I’ll give back the money plus interest without any fees.
3) Seller is afraid we won’t make their payment. Minimize with education.
First of all, most sellers I deal with are about to loose their house and already have 2-5 late payments on their record. They don’t have much to loose, especially since I’ll give them money for their equity. Better then loosing the property, getting a foreclosure and getting no money. Second, if I’m investing 10K+ into a deal why would I not make the payments and loose my investment? I’m catching up their loan, improving their credit and helping them get a fresh start. The seller has much more to gain then they have to loose
Ok, now I knew for sure that this was definitely a scam. I said no thanks and politely passed on the offer.
Here’s where it gets even more interesting. THE VERY NEXT WEEK, I received another email from Casey.
I haven’t told everybody the full story about the recent problems in my real estate business. I feel like I need to share my experience and tell it how it is. So I started a blog:
As I learn my lessons and find solutions I will be writing about it. Hopefully this will help others out there who may be going through the same thing.
Also let me know if you have any buyers for my properties. I’m ready to sell them below what I owe via a shortsale to avoid foreclosure.
Those who received my email about Private Money – please forgive me for giving you a false impression. Getting high returns lending on real estate deals is a good thing – you should do it. However, I didn’t fully explain MY situation. I made it seem like I had everything together. Well, as you can see, I’m not a very safe bet right now. As I recover from this thing and rebuild my business I hope to gain your trust over time. Then if you still want to get great returns we can talk. In the mean time I can refer you to other investors who already have a solid track record.
Thanks for your support.
Now this really made me mad. Casey had tried to sucker people into a scam real-estate deal less than a week before he admitted he was going through foreclosure. I was fortunate enough to recognize his pitch as bullshit, but what if someone had gotten conned into it? Financial scams on unsuspecting people make me furious. So I read through his site. It turns out that he had bought multiple houses in different states (hoping to flip them quickly), lied on his applications to get his loans approved, and had grossly miscalculated how much it would cost to renovate and flip them. Bad move. His debt is now over $2 million.
But this isn’t just a 1-dimensional character who deserves our scorn. I know Casey and he’s actually a very nice and sincere guy. We met at a Starbucks a couple weeks ago (he had been invited to give a talk at UC Berkeley), and he filled me in on the details. If you read through his blog, you’ll see that he’s being completely honest about what he did wrong, and he’s accepting responsibility for his situation–despite the thousands of angry comments on his blog. It seems that there are lots and lots of people angry about the housing bubble, both from the people who made stupid choices and screwed themselves by being greedy and the “I told you so” people.
Things have been going all right for him. He’s managed to sell one of his houses, and his press attention has been sending thousands of people to his blog. In fact, Robert Kiyosaki (author of Rich Dad, Poor Dad, which I reviewed here) heard about Casey’s story and invited him to meet in Phoenix.
Will Casey get out of debt without having to declare bankrupcy? I don’t know. I honestly don’t know what to make of this situation. But I do think a few things: First, Casey really messed up by trying to con people into joining his stupid real-estate “opportunity.” That was a scam, pure and simple, and every single one of you needs to beware of that in the future–no matter if your age-old high-school friend pitches you, or your best friend. A scam is a scam. Second, Casey did at least acknowledge his wrongdoing a few days later and invited people to his blog to view his progress. He’s been remarkably positive despite the horrendously negative comments he’s getting. Even when I met him, he knew exactly the situation he was in, and he was still positive about the future. I think that’s pretty impressive. And I’m pretty amazed by what he’s done in 2 months: He’s created a great blog to share what he did wrong, and he’s gotten massive media attention to spread the word.
Is it really right to be starting a blog when you’re over $2 million in debt? Honestly, I wouldn’t be doing it. I’d be doing every single thing I could to sell those properties and (this may be the only time you ever hear me say this) get a stable job. Sometimes, you need to bite the bullet. But he’s chosen a different path and I guess we’ll see how it goes.
This is a blog on personal finance and personal entrepreneurship for young people. To see more articles from iwillteachyoutoberich.com, check out my table of contents (over 300 posts), my RSS feed, and my newsletter.