You aren't good at picking mutual funds!

Posted at 8:27 on Wednesday April 20, 2005 | Filed Under Investing

Remember when I wrote about how foolish actively managed mutual funds are in most cases? (Link: Don't some active mutual funds beat index funds?) I've also written broadly about mutual funds: All about mutual funds

Anyway, in those articles, I pointed out in 9/10 cases, buying an actively managed mutual fund is a sucker's game. I suggested index funds as a better way to start investing.

Now check out what Jonathan Clements, the fantastic personal-finance writer from the Wall Street Journal, has to say.

Suppose, at year end 1969, that you had ranked diversified U.S. stock funds based on their 10-year performance and then bought the top 25%. Result: Over the next 10 years, you would have lagged behind the S&P 500, according to calculations using Lipper data by the Bogle Financial Markets Research Center in Malvern, Pa.

Similarly, the top performers from the 1970s were stock-market laggards in the 1980s, and the top performers from the 1980s fell behind the S&P 500 in the 1990s. And the current decade isn't looking too good, either. The top 25% of stock funds from the 1990s have fallen 5.2% a year during the past five calendar years, trailing the S&P 500's 2.3% annual loss.


In other words:
  • We are very, very bad at choosing mutual funds (just as we are generally bad at picking stocks, actually)
  • Past performance is no indicator of future performance. Yes, every fund writes this on all their ads, but everybody pooh-poohs it and doesn't really care. IT REALLY IS TRUE.
  • Buying an actively managed fund (where you're paying 2-3% for someone to manage your money) cuts into your profits even more, making it unlikely you'll even beat the market (a relatively dim goal for sophisticated investors). Remember, about 85% of actively managed mutual funds fail to beat the market.

Although I drill this point in my classes, it seems that the best audience for this advice is your parents--and we all have parents who are in actively managed mutual funds. Talk to them and you'll be surprised what they know about their own investments!

PS--I sent out another IWillTeachYouToBeRich newsletter yesterday. If you're not subscribed, you're missing out on exclusive articles and links that I never post here. Subscribe! (See below.)

Now what?
DONE READING?
Now you can leave your own comment or subscribe to the newsletter

Leave your comment

NOTE
Fields marked with asterisk (*) are required.
:
:
:
remember me:
(You may use HTML tags for style)

getting started

This is a blog on personal finance (banking, saving, budgeting, and investing) and personal entrepreneurship.

It's for students, recent graduates, and other young people.

about me

Ramit Sethi

I'm a recent graduate of Stanford, where I studied technology and psychology. Now I'm the co-founder & VP of Marketing for PBwiki, a wiki startup in Silicon Valley.

categories
stay tuned

Stay current with updates:
Sign up for the free newsletter...

...or use RSS / Atom feed:

RSS FeedAtom Feed